Choosing a new shingle color is one of the biggest decisions homeowners make during a roof replacement. Your roof makes up nearly half of your home’s curb appeal, and the color you choose can completely change the look and feel of your exterior. In Pittsburgh, where neighborhoods mix historic charm with modern styles, homeowners tend to gravitate toward colors that are timeless, versatile, and weather-friendly.
Here’s a full guide to the shingle colors Pittsburgh homeowners love most—and why they continue to trend year after year.
Why Shingle Color Matters
Shingle color does more than make your home “look nice.” It also affects:
Curb appeal — The right color enhances trim, siding, stone, and brick.
Resale value — A well-chosen color makes your home more appealing to future buyers.
Neighborhood style — Choosing a color that fits your community helps your home blend in or stand out—in a good way.
Since you’ll likely have your roof for the next 50 years, selecting a color you’ll love long-term is essential.
The Most Popular Shingle Colors in Pittsburgh
Based on local style trends, common exterior materials in the region, and homeowner preferences, these are the top shingle colors seen throughout Pittsburgh communities.
1. Moire Black
Deep black shingles remain a top choice in Western PA. They create a bold, clean contrast and instantly modernize a home.
Why Pittsburgh homeowners love it:
Works beautifully with white, beige, light gray, and red brick homes
Gives a sleek, timeless finish
Looks sharp year-round, from snowy winters to sunny summer days
Best for: Modern homes, colonials, craftsman-style houses, and any home needing stronger contrast.
2. Georgetown Gray
Gray is one of the most versatile roofing colors in the region. Medium grays balance warm and cool tones, making them a safe and stylish choice for almost any home.
Why it’s popular:
Pairs well with stonework, brick, and vinyl siding
Doesn’t show dirt or staining as easily as lighter shingles
Offers a modern but not too bold look
Best for: Homes with stone facades, taupe siding, blue shutters, or neutral trim.
3.Weathered Wood
Warm brown-gray tones are hugely popular in Pittsburgh suburbs and traditional neighborhoods. This color mimics the look of natural wood shakes, giving homes a warm, earthy feel.
Why homeowners choose it:
Adds richness and depth to the home’s exterior
Matches well with tan, cream, and earth-tone siding
Blends beautifully in heavily wooded or natural surroundings
Best for: Traditional homes, ranch homes, and properties surrounded by trees or greenery.
4. Cobblestone Gray
Cool gray tones offer a polished, crisp look perfect for homes with blue, white, or cool-toned exteriors.
Why it’s trending:
Complements modern and classic architecture
Creates a clean, elevated look
Harmonizes well with Pittsburgh’s frequent cloudy skies and muted lighting
Best for: New builds, modern styles, or homes with cool paint colors.
5. Coastal Blue
Blue-gray shingles have become more popular in recent years as homeowners look for subtle ways to stand out.
Why homeowners love it:
Adds personality without being overpowering
Works exceptionally well with gray, white, or navy exteriors
Gives homes a coastal or modern aesthetic—unique for Pittsburgh
Best for: Modern homes, contemporary renovations, and homes with blue or gray siding.
6. Evergreen
Though less common, green shingles remain a favorite for homeowners wanting a natural, earthy, distinctive style.
Why it works:
Complements wooded properties and natural landscapes
Offers a warm, organic feel that stands apart from typical neutrals
Pairs well with tan or cream siding and rustic architectural elements
Best for: Homes in wooded or rural settings, cottages, cabins, and craftsman-style homes.
How to Choose the Right Color for Your Home
Here are a few tips to ensure the color you pick looks amazing on your specific property:
1. Match permanent features
Your siding, brick, stone, and trim should guide your decision. Roofs look best when the tone complements the house’s fixed elements.
2. Look at your roof in natural light
Colors can look drastically different in shade, snow, sunlight, or cloudy weather—very important in Pittsburgh’s four distinct seasons.
3. Consider neighborhood consistency
A roof color that fits the style of nearby homes generally improves curb appeal and resale value.
4. Think long-term
Your roof should still look good to you—and potential buyers—10–20 years from now. Trendy is fun, but timeless usually wins.
5. Use a visualizer
EAS Roofing can show you how different shingle colors will look on your specific home, taking the guesswork out of picking a favorite.
Final Thoughts
Your roof color is a major part of your home’s identity. Whether you prefer deep modern blacks, warm browns, classic grays, or something unique like blue or green, Pittsburgh homeowners have plenty of fantastic options to choose from.
At EAS Roofing, we help homeowners pick colors that enhance curb appeal, improve value, and fit perfectly with their home’s individual style. If you want to explore color options or see real samples on your home, our team is here to help.
Subscribe to EAS Roofing's Blog
Comments